As the clip begins it starts with a birds eye view of the
two boys sitting in the room together, the birds eye view is showing there is
distance between the two characters. You
are able to acknowledge the disabled boy side of the room as it childish as it
is messy, bright in colour and the toys situated every where. On the other hand
you can see the other boys room represents a typical teenager, the full colours
represent he lives a normal life. Non-digested sound is used, which is the
brother speaking over the clip talking about different ways of killing his
brother because he is disabled. This shows he is not comfortable with having a
disabled sibling and on the plus side he must look after him. He probably also embarrassed of having a
disabled brother as disabled people are looked down upon in society and treated
the same. The close up towards the end of clip shows the disabled boy as a
victim and very venerable. The clip
fades away as it is important to the other child.
The next scene is in the kitchen the camera is closed up on
the disabled boy once again to emphasise on his disability. On the other hand
when the abled child is standing, the camera is at a low angle, which
represents that he has more power physically, then the brother. Shot reverse shot
is used in the conversation between the abled brother and disabled brother, you
notice that the camera stays on the abled brother much longer then the disabled
brother this represents that the disabled brother is less important, in
society’s point of view. You are able to see the divide in society. When the
parents are talking to the abled child there is no soft tone, the sentences are
snappy and straight to the point. Whereas the disabled brother is spoken to
softly. which makes him feel safe and
comfortable. The disabled child is spoken to as a little child.
The next scene is in the park. The camera closes up to the
disabled child on the bike. In the close up you can see his dad helping him
this represents that he is unable to things on his own and requires
support. The close up is seen through a
gun target, which makes the disabled boy looked as a victim once again. The
brother is then shown shooting the brother with a smile on his face this shows
you his emotions he has towards disabled people. You then see the disabled
child doing child activates for example eating ice cream and a medium shot used
when flying a kite this shows that the boy has not matured as a teenager.
This clip is reinforcing the stereotypes of disability as
the disabled boy is portrayed as a victim and given more sympathy then to
someone who is able. The able brother is seen as a villain as he shows no kind
emotions towards his brother, which also tells you he does not think disabled
and abled people are equal.
Non-digested - diegetic
ReplyDeletevenerable - vulnerable
and a medium shot used - why, what does this distance say about disability?
Rather overly descriptive at times, your essay tells me the story rather than linking the evidence/examples with reasons for the stereotype (ie the edit means...).
There are some accurate points about the representation of disability and the Macro meaning behind the representation, but the textual evidence is not used to back this up or with terminology.
Mise-en-scene is partly covered and you need to be more thorough in your notes. The
lesson we prepared for this focused on how we can predict the aspects we will see - ie shot rev shot, close ups, foley. You need to work with your mentor partner and prepare for class to make gains from the development of this learning in the lessons. If you are serious about continuing with Media next year I would recommend you see me for study support with your mentor partner to discuss the steps for imporvement.
To improve:
Revise and apply the sub categories of the 4 technical areas - these are on the blog, wall of the classroom and other students blogs.
Prepare the stereotypes we will study so you use class time effectively and don't fall behind
Learn your terminology and stereotypes - gives reasons linked to these to pick up the marks.
AAE 14/20
EX 11/20
T 3/10
28/50 D